9 Best Underglaze Pencils for 2026

ChiPigments Underglaze Pencils 10-Pack is the Best Overall pick for an all-color option. For black marks, consider Chester’s Clay Black Underglaze Pencil, Pasler Black Underglaze Pencil Pair, or ZZYFGH Black Underglaze Pencils 2-Pack; for multiple colors, the shortlist includes SHAOQINLIN 10-Color, Marspark 15-Color, gisgfim Water-Based, gisgfim Oil-Based, and ChiPigments Brights 5-Pack.
Choose by surface, color, and firing range. Smooth bisque helps protect fragile pencil tips, and rough ceramic surfaces wear them down faster. Firing limits can vary by color: AMACO’s listed maximum ranges from Cone 05 for red to Cone 10 for blue, black, and green.
The comparison table covers surface compatibility, colors included, and pencil count.
Our top picks for underglaze pencils
- Best Overall: ChiPigments Underglaze Pencils 10-Pack, for multicolor pencil linework and details on bisque or leather-hard clay
- Best for Cone 06-10 Firing: Chester’s Clay Black Underglaze Pencil, for a fine black pencil line
- Best for Black Detail: Pasler Black Underglaze Pencil Pair, for black pencil detail on bisque or greenware
| ChiPigments Underglaze Pencils 10-Pack | ![]() | Best Overall | Surface compatibility: Bisque; leather-hard greenware | Colors included: 10 colors, multicolor | Pencil count: 10 pencils | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Chester’s Clay Black Underglaze Pencil | ![]() | Best for Cone 06-10 Firing | Surface compatibility: Bisque, greenware, bone dry pieces | Colors included: Black only (single color) | Pencil count: 2 pencils | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Pasler Black Underglaze Pencil Pair | ![]() | Best for Black Detail | Surface compatibility: Bisque and greenware | Colors included: Black only | Pencil count: 2 pencils | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| ZZYFGH Black Underglaze Pencils 2-Pack | ![]() | Best for Case Storage | Surface compatibility: Bisque and greenware | Colors included: Black; colorful option listed | Pencil count: 2 pencils | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| SHAOQINLIN 10-Color Underglaze Pencil Set | ![]() | Best for Ten-Color Variety | Surface compatibility: Pottery, porcelain | Colors included: 10 colors (yellow to dark green) | Pencil count: 10 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Marspark 15-Color Underglaze Pencil Set | ![]() | Best for 15-Color Variety | Surface compatibility: Bisque and greenware (per title) | Colors included: 15 colors, multicolor set | Pencil count: 15 pencils | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| gisgfim Water-Based Underglaze Pencil Set | ![]() | Best for Water-Based Bisque | Surface compatibility: Bisque | Colors included: 10 colors | Pencil count: 10 pencils | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| gisgfim Oil-Based Underglaze Pencil Set | ![]() | Best for Oil-Based Colors | Surface compatibility: Bisque painting stated | Colors included: 12 distinct hues | Pencil count: 12 pencils | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| ChiPigments® Brights 5-Pack Underglaze Pencils for Pottery | ![]() | Best for Glass and Greenware | Surface compatibility: Bisqueware; leather-hard greenware | Colors included: Red, yellow, light green, light blue, orange | Pencil count: 5 pencils | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
More Details on Our Top Picks
ChiPigments Underglaze Pencils 10-Pack
For potters who need color and detail across clay stages, this 10-pencil set is the broad all-around choice. It covers bisque and leather-hard clay, with 10 colors for outlines, lettering, and layered marks. You can blend marks with water or a stump, and firing makes them permanent. The set also includes a protective case, sanding pad, and pointer file.
Use the included pointer file to sharpen points, while the sanding pad and case support upkeep and storage. The pencils also suit frit-coated fusible glass, extending their use beyond clay. Some users report that the pencils can chip during use, and yellow may not hold well under dipping clear glaze.
Pros: Potter reported good results on pottery · Owner reported sharpening with electric pencil sharpener · Wet use may help application on bisque.
Cons: User reported pencils can chip during use · Yellow reportedly may not stay well under dipping clear glaze.
Skip it if: your designs depend on yellow marks staying intact under dipped clear glaze.
- Surface compatibility:Bisque; leather-hard greenware
- Firing range:—
- Colors included:10 colors, multicolor
- Pencil count:10 pencils
- Clear glaze:—
- Included accessories:Case, sanding pad, pointer file
Chester’s Clay Black Underglaze Pencil
With a cone 06–10 firing range, Chester’s Clay suits potters who need a fine black line across firing schedules. It sharpens to a fine point for outlining, labeling, signing, and detail on bisque, greenware, or bone-dry clay. Marks stay intact before firing unless wet, and black intensifies after firing.
Sharpen it with a pencil sharpener or fettling knife; the set includes 2 pencils, 1 sharpener, and 2 waterproof cases. It supports blending, stippling, crosshatching, erasing, smearing, scumbling, and burnishing, and works with seven glaze brands. The limitation is black only, so color variation must come from another pencil. Its cone 10 ceiling suits higher-temperature firings.
Skip it if: you need multiple pencil colors for colored outlines or shading.
- Surface compatibility:Bisque, greenware, bone dry pieces
- Firing range:Cone 06 (1855°F) to cone 10 (2381°F)
- Colors included:Black only (single color)
- Pencil count:2 pencils
- Clear glaze:—
- Included accessories:1 sharpener, 2 waterproof pencil cases
Pasler Black Underglaze Pencil Pair
Pasler’s pair suits potters drawing black detail on bisque or greenware, especially fine lines and shading. The two black pencils give you pencil-like control for detailed marks and work from Cone 06–10 (999–1,305°C). They’re non-toxic and lead-free, with a refund or replacement guarantee if they don’t meet expectations.
You can use them on bisque or greenware, and smoother bisque makes drawing easier because ceramic pencil tips wear quickly on rough surfaces. Owners report a waxier feel than AMACO pencils, along with more chipping and black marks that may fire silvery dark blue rather than very dark. For shading and fine work, this pair keeps the palette to black.
Pros: Can be used on bisque or greenware · Suitable for fine-line drawing and shading · It works up to cone 10.
Cons: It can chip more than Amaco pencils · Black may fire silvery dark blue rather than very dark.
Skip it if: your work calls for multiple pencil colors to outline or shade.
- Surface compatibility:Bisque and greenware
- Firing range:Cone 06–10 (999–1,305°C)
- Colors included:Black only
- Pencil count:2 pencils
- Clear glaze:—
- Included accessories:—
ZZYFGH Black Underglaze Pencils 2-Pack
Unlike Chester’s Clay Black Pencil, this pair suits potters who want black pencils stored in a waterproof case. The ZZYFGH set contains two pencils for shading, fine lines, coloring, and test-tile marks. It works on bisque and greenware across cone 06–10, giving you flexibility across firing ranges. Potters report that wetting the pencil helps it move smoothly on bisque.
The waterproof case keeps both pencils together between sessions, and the black color suits detailed drawings or tile labels. You can use the pencils on greenware as well as bisque, with shading and coloring among their intended uses. Owners report that the pencils can feel gritty when dry, may need repeated dipping in water, and can chip during use. Keep the case handy so the pair stays together, and wet the pencil when drawing on bisque.
Pros: Potter reported the pencils work fine · Owner reported use for marking test tiles · Wet application was reported to go on smoothly.
Cons: Owner reported pencils chip during use · Owners reported they can feel gritty when dry.
Skip it if: you need a pencil that won’t chip during use.
- Surface compatibility:Bisque and greenware
- Firing range:Cone 06–10
- Colors included:Black; colorful option listed
- Pencil count:2 pencils
- Clear glaze:—
- Included accessories:Waterproof case
SHAOQINLIN 10-Color Underglaze Pencil Set
Decorators who want range in one box can start with this ten-color variety pack. The set includes yellow, orange, red, coffee, black, gray, light blue, dark blue, light green, and dark green. It works for shading, fine lines, and detail on pottery and porcelain. Its concentrated pigment core produces strong color after firing.
The box includes an organizer with holder and a frosted foam pad, so the set stays together. Check the firing limit for each shade before use.
What to check: Test a sample of each shade under your clear glaze before you decorate a finished piece.
Pros: Listing includes ten colors for varied drawing · Organizer and holder are included · Frosted foam pad is included.
Cons: Listing does not specify bisque or greenware compatibility · Listing does not state whether clear glaze is required.
Skip it if: you decorate greenware; these pencils are for pottery and porcelain.
- Surface compatibility:Pottery, porcelain
- Firing range:1100–1300 degrees
- Colors included:10 colors (yellow to dark green)
- Pencil count:10
- Clear glaze:—
- Included accessories:Pencil organizer with holder, frosted foam pad
Marspark 15-Color Underglaze Pencil Set
Home DIY, classroom, and gift makers who want 15-color variety in one set will find it here. The set covers basic and commonly used shades for outlines, shading, and lettering. Each pencil has a fine tip for smooth lines, patterns, and lettering, and the ink flow is designed to minimize drips.
Tips wear quickly on abrasive surfaces, so rough greenware will dull that fine point faster.
Skip it if: you draw on rough greenware, which wears down the fine tip quickly.
- Surface compatibility:Bisque and greenware (per title)
- Firing range:Up to 1280°C (2336°F)
- Colors included:15 colors, multicolor set
- Pencil count:15 pencils
- Clear glaze:—
- Included accessories:—
gisgfim Water-Based Underglaze Pencil Set
Bisque painters looking for a water-based set will like this 10-color pack of pigment-core pencils. The pigment core is rated for 1100–1300 °C firing, so the marks are meant to survive the kiln. Ceramic underglaze marks are made to stay through firing, unlike graphite.
Everything you need comes in the box: sharpener, eraser, and case. Use a hand sharpener, since electric models are discouraged for ceramic pencils. Handle it gently, since the leads are brittle and can break when rotated roughly.
Owners report the tip may need repeated wetting during use, and dipping it in water softens the lines. The 10 colors run from yellow and orange to dark blue and dark green.
What to check: Sand the bisque smooth before drawing, since rough surfaces wear pencil tips quickly.
Cons: Pottery users report tips may need repeated wetting during use (general category feedback).
Skip it if: you brush clear glaze over the marks, which can smudge.
- Surface compatibility:Bisque
- Firing range:1100–1300 °C
- Colors included:10 colors
- Pencil count:10 pencils
- Clear glaze:—
- Included accessories:Case, sharpener, eraser
gisgfim Oil-Based Underglaze Pencil Set
For fine lines on bisque, oil-based color users need a pencil that keeps a sharp point. This set gives you 12 hues for shading and outlines, rated for firing from 1100℃ to 1300℃. Bisque is clay fired hard enough to take mark-making pressure, and smoother bisque lets the lead glide.
The set includes a sharpener, an eraser for wrong lines, and a pen case that keeps the 12 pencils together. Owners say wetting the tip gives smoother marks, which helps on bisque. The leads are brittle, though, and tips can break or be hard to sharpen, so turn them gently and skip electric sharpeners. Apply clear glaze with care, because it can smear these pencil marks.
Pros: Ceramics users report smoother marks when pencil tips are wetted · Pottery users report pencils can work well for signing pieces · Users describe underglaze pencils as useful for fine lines and small details.
Cons: Pottery users report tips can break or be difficult to sharpen · Users report some pencils feel gritty or chalky when drawing.
Skip it if: you need a pencil with tips that sharpen easily and don’t break.
- Surface compatibility:Bisque painting stated
- Firing range:1100–1300℃
- Colors included:12 distinct hues
- Pencil count:12 pencils
- Clear glaze:—
- Included accessories:Case, sharpener, eraser
ChiPigments® Brights 5-Pack Underglaze Pencils for Pottery
Five colors for frit-coated glass and leather-hard greenware make ChiPigments® Brights 5-Pack suited to potters decorating across surfaces. The set includes red, yellow, light green, light blue, and orange pencils for outlines, text, and layered color. Glass and greenware use gives you more options than a bisqueware-only set, while water or a stump can blend marks. A protective case and pencil pointer file come with the five pencils.
Application stays brush-free, with no brush cleanup, and owners report smoother drawing after wetting a pencil and wiping away excess moisture. One potter used the pencils to mark test tiles through Cone 10. Owners also report a gritty feel unless they repeatedly dip the pencil. Another owner says the pencils chip more during use than AMACO pencils, so expect to handle the leads carefully while making detailed marks.
Pros: Potter reports smoother application after wetting the pencil and wiping excess moisture away (2025) · One owner reports using pencils to mark test tiles through cone 10 firing (2025).
Cons: Pencils can chip more during use than AMACO pencils (2025) · Owner describes the texture as gritty unless repeatedly dipped in water (2026).
Skip it if: you don’t want to dip the pencil in water repeatedly to keep its marks smooth.
- Surface compatibility:Bisqueware; leather-hard greenware
- Firing range:—
- Colors included:Red, yellow, light green, light blue, orange
- Pencil count:5 pencils
- Clear glaze:—
- Included accessories:Storage case; pencil pointer file
Underglaze Pencils: Key Specs Side by Side
Here is how the 9 picks line up on surface compatibility, firing range, colors included, pencil count and included accessories. Cells marked with a dash are specs the maker leaves out of its listing.
| Pick | Surface compatibility | Firing range | Colors included | Pencil count | Included accessories |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ChiPigments Underglaze Pencils 10-Pack | Bisque; leather-hard greenware | — | 10 colors, multicolor | 10 pencils | Case, sanding pad, pointer file |
| Chester’s Clay Black Underglaze Pencil | Bisque, greenware, bone dry pieces | Cone 06 (1855°F) to cone 10 (2381°F) | Black only (single color) | 2 pencils | 1 sharpener, 2 waterproof pencil cases |
| Pasler Black Underglaze Pencil Pair | Bisque and greenware | Cone 06–10 (999–1,305°C) | Black only | 2 pencils | — |
| ZZYFGH Black Underglaze Pencils 2-Pack | Bisque and greenware | Cone 06–10 | Black; colorful option listed | 2 pencils | Waterproof case |
| SHAOQINLIN 10-Color Underglaze Pencil Set | Pottery, porcelain | 1100–1300 degrees | 10 colors (yellow to dark green) | 10 | Pencil organizer with holder, frosted foam pad |
| Marspark 15-Color Underglaze Pencil Set | Bisque and greenware (per title) | Up to 1280°C (2336°F) | 15 colors, multicolor set | 15 pencils | — |
| gisgfim Water-Based Underglaze Pencil Set | Bisque | 1100–1300 °C | 10 colors | 10 pencils | Case, sharpener, eraser |
| gisgfim Oil-Based Underglaze Pencil Set | Bisque painting stated | 1100–1300℃ | 12 distinct hues | 12 pencils | Case, sharpener, eraser |
| ChiPigments® Brights 5-Pack Underglaze Pencils for Pottery | Bisqueware; leather-hard greenware | — | Red, yellow, light green, light blue, orange | 5 pencils | Storage case; pencil pointer file |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Underglaze Pencils
Surface Compatibility for Bisque and Greenware
Choose a surface that can take a light pencil mark without putting pressure on the lead. For the best underglaze pencils, a smooth, firm surface is a better starting point than rough or soft clay.
- Bisque: Commercial underglaze pencils are normally used on bisque-fired clay that’s hardened enough to withstand mark-making pressure. Choose a firm, smooth surface; fragile leads are more likely to break on rough surfaces.
- Greenware: Guidance here focuses on bisque, so use bisque as your baseline when comparing products.
- Common mistake: Pressing harder to force a dark line. Choose a smoother surface because pencil leads can be fragile.
Firing Range Listed for Each Pencil
Match the pencil’s firing range to your planned firing, and pay attention to differences between colors. A range is useful only if it covers the firing you intend to use.
- Range: Compare the stated cone range with your kiln schedule. AMACO lists its underglaze pencil for Cone 05–10, while Chrysanthos is rated from Cone 06 (999°C) to Cone 10 (1,305°C). The useful range is the one that includes your planned cone.
- Color: Check firing limits by color rather than treating every color in a set as interchangeable. AMACO’s guide rates Medium Blue, Gray, Black, Brown, White, Dark Green, and Dark Blue for Cone 05–10.
- Common mistake: Choosing by the broadest range alone. If you’ll use several colors, make sure the specific color you need suits your firing temperature.
Colors Included in the Set
Choose colors for the marks you actually plan to make. A set with many colors can give you more options for outlines and shading, but color count alone doesn’t tell you whether the shades suit your work.
- Color range: Look for the hues you’ll use, such as a dark color for outlines or several shades for colored marks. AMACO’s guide lists seven colors rated for Cone 05–10.
- Firing by color: Treat firing suitability as part of color choice. A color that fits your design still needs to suit your planned firing.
- Common mistake: Assuming every color in a set shares the same firing limit. Compare each color’s range with the cone you plan to use.
Pencil Count and Single-Pencil Options
Choose the quantity that fits how you’ll use the pencils: one color for focused work, or several colors when you need more choice.
- Single pencil: A single-pencil option can suit you if you want one color or are replacing a pencil. AMACO’s shop lists a single-pencil purchase.
- Multi-pencil pack: A pack can give you more than one pencil, but the count doesn’t tell you which colors it includes. Chrysanthos offers individual pencils and a six-color pack.
- Common mistake: Buying by count alone. Match the pack size to your intended colors and the number of pencils you want on hand, rather than assuming a larger pack is a better fit.
Clear Glaze Testing Before Firing
Test the pencil under the clear glaze you plan to use. A test helps you judge how the line looks after glazing and firing, rather than relying on the dry mark alone.
- Test setup: Use the same surface and clear glaze planned for the finished work. Testing under the intended glaze is a supported selection criterion.
- Sharpness and durability can vary with surface and color.
- Firing: Keep the color’s firing limit in view when planning the test. Chrysanthos pencils are intended for bisque and should be covered with clear glaze before firing.
- Common mistake: Testing only the pencil mark, then changing the glaze or surface for the finished piece. Keep the test conditions aligned with the work you plan to make.
Included Erasers and Sharpeners
Treat included tools as a convenience, then judge the pencil on the fit that matters most: its surface compatibility, colors, and firing range.
- Eraser: An included eraser can help when you want to remove or revise a mark before firing. The gisgfim sets include an eraser.
- Sharpener: An included sharpener can help maintain a point for line work. The gisgfim sets include a sharpener.
- Common mistake: Letting the accessories decide the purchase. Give more weight to a suitable surface and firing range, since the lead can be fragile and firing limits can vary by color.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you sharpen underglaze pencils without breaking them?
Sharpen them with a manual tool rather than an electric sharpener, since the pencils are fragile and electric sharpeners are discouraged. Draw on smooth bisque, because abrasive surfaces wear the tip quickly.
Can you blend or smudge underglaze pencil marks?
Yes, you can. Soft images can be rubbed or smudged with a finger to create tones. Marks can be made with either the tip or the side of the pencil, which gives you more ways to build tone.
Why do underglaze pencil colors look different after firing?
Colors fire differently because each one has its own maximum cone, and AMACO lists Cone 05 for red but Cone 10 for blue, black, and green. Test each shade under your intended clear glaze, since line sharpness and results can vary by surface and color.
How do underglaze pencils compare with ceramic crayons?
Underglaze pencils are built for detail work, including shading, fine-line drawing, and identification on bisque. Choose pencils when you need a sharp line or lettering, since the tip or side can build both lines and soft tones.
Are underglaze pencils non-toxic and lead-free?
Yes, they’re made from clays, colorants, and refractory materials rather than graphite. Unlike graphite marks, they’re intended to remain through firing, so the fired surface shows the pencil’s own pigment.
Conclusion
Choose a black pair when fine lines matter more than color, or a multi-color set when you need varied outlines and shading. Match your choice to the clay surface and firing range you plan to use, then test your intended marks and glaze on a sample tile before decorating a finished piece.
Sources
- How to Make and Use Underglaze Pencils, Pens, Crayons and Trailers (ceramicartsnetwork.org)
- downloads.ctfassets.net
- Chester's Clay – Black Underglaze Pencil – Pottery Glaze for Ceramic Bisque, Greenware and Bone Dry Pieces – Sharpens to (bmmarts.com)
- Underglaze Pottery Pencil Kit – Pasler Pottery (pasler-art.com)
- gisgfim 10Pcs Underglaze Pencils Water-Based Underglaze Pencil Set Under Glaze Ceramic Pencils Ceramic Colored Pencil In (ibspot.com)
- amaco.com
- chrysanthos.com
- shop.amaco.com
- tuckers-pottery-supplies-inc.shoplightspeed.com















